If you’ve been around my world for a while, you know I’m a big fan of collaborations… and that includes bundles. I’ve participated in dozens of them over the years, and they’ve been a fantastic way to grow my email list, connect with other entrepreneurs, and share my resources with new audiences.
Disclaimer: I earn from qualifying purchases. Some of the links on my website are affiliate links, which means, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase.
But after all that experience, I’ve noticed a pattern: while bundles are great for exposure, the highest-quality leads and best ROI for my time often come from a different visibility strategy.
What strategy? Podcast guesting.
For introverts like me, podcast guesting can be a much more sustainable way to reach new people.
You’re able to have a deeper, more personal conversation with an audience that already trusts the host. That connection lasts far longer than the bundle promo window and it often leads to more engaged subscribers and clients.
In this post, I’ll share my best podcast guesting tips for introverts and explain why, even though I still love bundles, podcast interviews consistently deliver stronger results for my business.
Why Podcast Guesting Works for Introverts
For introverts, visibility isn’t just about reaching more people. It’s about doing it in a way that feels good and doesn’t drain every ounce of energy.
That’s where podcast guesting really shines.
1. A Low-Pressure Environment
Unlike summits or live events, podcast guesting is typically a one-on-one conversation with the host. There’s no live audience staring at you, no need to be “on” for hours, and no juggling a big presentation.
It’s just a focused chat (from the comfort of your own home) about topics you already know inside and out.
2. Content That Lives Longer
Bundle promos usually last a week or less.
Once they’re over, that traffic stops.
Podcast episodes, however, live online for years. New listeners can discover your interview months (or even years) later, giving you ongoing exposure without any extra effort on your part.
3. Built-In Warm Audience
When you guest on a podcast, you’re speaking to a community that already trusts the host. That warm introduction makes it easier for listeners to trust you, too. They’re much more likely to check out your lead magnet, join your email list, or follow you on social media.
4. ROI That’s Easier to Track
Podcast interviews are more targeted by nature.
The people tuning in are there because they’re interested in the topic, so your opt-in and conversion rates often end up higher than the broad, “everyone join” approach of bundles.
The Downsides of Bundles for Introverts
Let me be clear: I genuinely love bundles. I’ve participated in dozens, and they’ve helped me grow my audience, collaborate with amazing business owners, and connect with people who might never have found me otherwise.
They absolutely have their place in a marketing strategy.
But after all that experience, I’ve also noticed a few drawbacks… especially when I compare them to podcast guesting.
1. Short Promo Window
Most bundles run for a limited time, usually about 5–7 days. Once the promo ends, that burst of visibility is over. If someone misses the sign-up window, the opportunity to connect with them is gone.
2. Competing for Attention
Bundles often feature dozens of contributors.
While that’s great for variety, it also means your offer is sitting alongside many others. For introverts, it can feel harder to stand out in such a crowded space, especially if you’re not someone who thrives on constant promo hype.
3. Less Targeted Leads
Bundles bring in large numbers of new subscribers, but those subscribers are a mix of people with different needs, interests, and levels of engagement.
You might see a spike in your list size, but not all of those leads will be a perfect fit for your offers.
4. More Setup and Tech Work
Between creating graphics, writing copy, setting up delivery pages, and updates, there’s often a bigger upfront workload with bundles.
For me, these factors don’t make bundles bad. They just mean I use them differently now. They’re still a great visibility tool, but I know that podcast guesting often gives me deeper connections, higher-quality leads, and longer-lasting results.
How to Get Started with Podcast Guesting
If you’re ready to give podcast guesting a try, the good news is… you don’t need a huge media kit or years of experience to start landing interviews.
You just need a clear message, a few targeted shows to pitch, and a plan to show up prepared.
And if you want a proven process to organize your outreach and send personalized pitches that actually get responses, check out my Podcast Guesting Airtable System.
1. Identify Your Target Podcasts
Don’t just aim for the biggest shows in your industry. Aim for the right ones.
A smaller podcast with your exact target audience will often give you a higher ROI than a huge show with a broad, mixed listener base.
- Search Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Listen Notes for keywords related to your industry or topics.
- Pay attention to shows that regularly feature guests.
- Listen to an episode or two to make sure your style and message are a fit.
- Find a guest who was on your perfect fit podcast talking about the same thing you do? Do a Google Search of their name to see what other podcasts they’ve been on that you can pitch!
2. Craft a Pitch That Stands Out
A great pitch is about the host’s audience, not just your expertise.
- Lead with a topic that directly benefits their listeners.
- Keep it short and personal.
- Mention a specific episode you enjoyed or a point you connected with.
- Clearly explain what you bring to the conversation.
You can organize and personalize all your pitches using my Podcast Guesting Airtable System so nothing slips through the cracks.
3. Prepare for the Interview
The more prepared you are, the more confident you’ll feel, especially as an introvert.
- Outline 3–5 key points you want to cover.
- Have stories or examples ready to illustrate each one.
- Practice clear, concise answers without scripting every word.
Maximizing ROI From Every Podcast Appearance
Landing the interview is just the first step. What you do before, during, and after the episode can make a huge difference in your results.
1. Share Your Best Tips During the Episode
Don’t hold back your best advice for fear of “giving away too much.” The more value you deliver in the interview, the more trust you’ll build with listeners, and the more likely they are to connect with you afterward.
2. Offer a Specific Freebie for That Audience
Instead of directing listeners to your homepage, give them a free resource that directly connects to the topic you discussed.
Use a custom URL (or UTM codes) so you can track sign-ups and tailor your follow-up emails to that audience.
3. Promote the Episode Once It’s Live
When the episode airs, share it with your email list, social media followers, and any communities you’re part of. This not only helps your own audience but also supports the host. And that strengthens that relationship for future collaborations.
4. Repurpose Your Interview
One podcast interview can fuel multiple pieces of content:
- Turn key points into social media posts.
- Expand your talking points into a blog post.
- Share audio clips or quotes as teasers.
Repurposing extends the life of your interview and makes the most of your time investment.
Tips for Managing Energy as an Introverted Guest
1. Schedule with Buffer Time
Avoid booking back-to-back interviews. Give yourself space before and after each recording so you can prepare mentally, reset, and recharge.
2. Record at Your Peak Energy Time
If you know you’re more focused in the morning, try to schedule interviews then. Recording at your natural high-energy time will help you feel more relaxed and confident.
3. Keep Notes and Water Nearby
Even if you’ve prepped your talking points, having a few quick prompts written down can help keep your thoughts organized. And don’t underestimate the power of staying hydrated. Your voice will thank you.
4. Build in Recovery Space
After an interview, give yourself permission to take a break before diving back into work. As introverts, we often process conversations internally, so downtime helps you recharge for the next thing.
Final Thoughts
I still love bundles. They’ve been a huge part of my visibility strategy, and I’ll continue to participate in them. But after doing dozens over the years, I’ve seen firsthand that podcast guesting often delivers a higher ROI and better-quality leads, especially for introverts.
Why? Because it’s not just about quick exposure. It’s about connection.
A podcast interview gives you the chance to have a genuine conversation, share your expertise in context, and be introduced to an audience that already trusts the host. That combination builds deeper relationships and leads that are more likely to convert into clients or customers.
If you’ve been relying heavily on bundles and want to diversify your visibility strategy, podcast guesting is a powerful option to explore. Start small, target the right shows, and make every interview count.
And if you want a simple way to organize your outreach and send personalized pitches that actually get responses, my Podcast Guesting Airtable System will help you land more interviews without the overwhelm.
Because visibility doesn’t have to be loud, draining, or complicated. It just has to be aligned with you.
FAQ: Podcast Guesting for Introverts
1. How do I find podcasts that fit my niche?
Search platforms like Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Listen Notes using keywords your ideal audience would use. Look for shows that regularly feature guests and have content aligned with your expertise. Focus on podcasts with engaged audiences rather than just high download numbers.
2. What should I include in a podcast guest pitch?
Your pitch should be short, personal, and audience-focused. Mention why you love their show, propose a topic that benefits their listeners, and highlight your relevant experience. My Podcast Guesting Airtable System includes a pitch tracker + automated process, so you can stay organized and personalize every outreach.
3. How do I make the most of being a podcast guest?
Deliver your best tips during the interview, share a relevant freebie with a custom/UTM link for that audience, and promote the episode once it’s live. Repurpose the content into blog posts, social media, or email content for extra reach.
4. What if I’m nervous about speaking on a podcast?
Nerves are normal! Choose topics you’re confident about, outline a few key points, and practice answering questions aloud.
Remember: podcasts are conversations, not live TV. Most hosts will edit out mistakes, so you can relax and be yourself.
5. Why is podcast guesting better than bundles for introverts?
Bundles are great for quick exposure, but podcast guesting allows for deeper connection with a warm audience, longer-lasting content, and often higher-quality leads. It’s also a lower-pressure, more sustainable visibility option for many introverts.
This one's on me. Complimentary free stuff coming right up.
leaving so soon?
The training vault contains on-demand access to several trainings and presentations around growing your business and creating additional revenue streams.
the training vault library
Want to learn the 4 marketing methods that work best for most introverts + how to use them effectively to grow your business? This free webinar covers it all.
market your business as an introvert
Featured Masterclasses:
Here's your FREE pass!
