How to Build Social Confidence as an Introvert with Caroline Smith

Do you ever feel awkward in social situations… like you’re the only one who doesn’t know what to say? You’re not alone. In this episode of the Introvertpreneur Podcast, I’m joined by Caroline Smith, founder of The Introverted Misfit. She’s on a mission to help shy, awkward introverts become socially confident without pretending to be someone they’re not.

Caroline shares her personal journey from social anxiety and awkwardness to running a thriving business built around authenticity and confidence. This conversation is packed with practical advice you can start applying today if you’ve ever struggled with making connections, starting conversations, or feeling “too introverted” to fit in.

Disclaimer: I earn from qualifying purchases. Some of the links on my website are affiliate links, which means, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase.

In this episode, Caroline and I dive into:

  • Caroline’s journey from socially anxious teen to socially confident entrepreneur
  • Small first steps to start building confidence in everyday interactions
  • How to initiate conversations without overthinking
  • Simple ways to appear more approachable (even if you have “resting unfriendly face”)
  • Why recharging rituals matter for introverts after social events
  • …and much more

A Breakdown of This Episode

[00:00] Caroline’s story and autism diagnosis at 17

[05:30] Small, everyday steps to build social confidence

[09:00] Conversation starters, awkward moments, and even clown bow ties

[11:30] How to approach people when starting conversations feels impossible

[13:30] Resting face struggles + tricks to look more approachable

[20:50] Recharge rituals: comfort shows, books, and hot chocolate

[22:20] Inside Caroline’s Communicate with Quiet, Quirky Confidence program

[26:30] Why action steps matter more than “just changing your mindset”

[27:30] Where to connect with Caroline + her free audio guide

If you enjoyed this episode, I invite you to drop a five-star rating + review with your biggest takeaway, so that other introverts can find this podcast for guidance and support through their introvert entrepreneur journey!

Download the Episode Transcript

Final Thoughts

I loved this conversation with Caroline because it’s such a powerful reminder that introverts don’t need to “fix” themselves to thrive socially. Small steps, self-awareness, and leaning into your quirks can help you build genuine confidence that feels natural… not forced.

If this episode resonated with you, I encourage you to check out Caroline’s website, The Introverted Misfit, and her free guide on starting conversations.

And as always, if you’re ready to grow your business in a way that feels sustainable and introvert-friendly, explore my free resources or join the Introvertpreneur Club for deeper support.

Resources Mentioned in the Show